The Court Report
By Richard Blassberg
State Supreme Court, White Plains
Judge Lester Adler Presiding
Monday, August 21st Defendant Jesse O’Brien, charged with First and Second Degree Robbery, and Second Degree Assault, as well as lesser felonies, in a seven-count indictment arising from an incident in Yonkers, appeared for a pre-trial hearing before Judge Lester Adler. O’Brien was accompanied by his Attorney, Richard Candee, who announced at the start of the hearing that he possessed T-Mobil cell phone records and Sony Corporation computer usage records that would place his client, at the time of the incident with which he is charged, in a situation that would tend to make it “doubtful that he engaged in the criminal activity he is charged with.”
Responding to Mr. Candee, Assistant District Attorney Calvin Scholar, addressing the Court, declared that any such materials constitute an alibi, and, as such, needed to be turned over to his office. Attorney Candee responded, “Sony records of the use of his computer at, or about, the time of the alleged crime does not constitute an alibi, and thus we are not bound to turn over such records to the DA’s Office.”
Judge Adler, who had met with the attorneys, in chambers, prior to entering the courtroom, now offered, “By denying that you committed the act in this case, under New York State law constitutes an alibi.” Mr. Scholar followed with, “If Mr. Candee presents a witness by way of establishing an alibi, it is our position that we are entitled to that information.” Judge Adler then asked, “Is the person who was on the phone able to state that the Defendant was at some other location at the time of the crime? The Court would submit that the records would serve only one purpose at the trial, to convince the jury that the Defendant was someplace else. The spirit of the legislation is such as to prevent surprise of the Prosecution. It looks like, and should be treated like alibi material.”
Mr. Candee, visibly upset with Adler’s position, now said, “I do have a strategy, and that strategy does not involve turning over my entire case before it is necessary to.” Mr. Scholar now informed the Court and the Defense that he had two witnesses waiting to be examined, Yonkers Detective Chiarello and Police Officer Rodriguez. He suggested that Mr. Candee might have wished to interview them privately before their appearances.
Candee, reluctant at first, then complied with a request by Adler that he, in fact, speak with the officers.
Following a brief adjournment, during which Mr. Candee availed himself of the opportunity to interview each officer, Judge Adler opened the hearing with, “By prior decision of this Court the Court has granted a hearing on the Defense motion to suppress identifications offered by the Prosecution.”
Mr. Candee immediately followed with a statement raising his concerns over a possible Brady material issue as might be involved with what he referred to as “conflicts” posed by the question of whether the perpetrator was described as White or Hispanic. There followed the presentation of Prosecution witnesses Yonkers Detective Sgt. Kevin Scully, and Detective Anthony Chiarello, as well as Police Officer Rodriguez. The purpose of the hearing was essentially to establish the reliability of the identification of the Defendant by police sources.
Analysis:
The issue here was whether Defense materials that are not being offered specifically to establish that an accused was somewhere other than at the crime scene, at the time of the alleged crime, but that might tend to suggest that he was not, must be treated as alibi evidence subject to release upon request by the Prosecution, under the rules of state legislation governing alibi evidence.
WORLD NEWS STORIES: Editor Brian Harrod Provides The Latest International News, Investigations And Analysis From Africa, The Americas, Asia, Australia, Canada, Europe, The Middle East And The U.K.
Web Stats Provided By Google Anaytics
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
This Just In To The Business News Desk
This Just In To The Health News Desk
Popular Harrod's News Of The World Posts - Last 7 Days
-
Two Nevada youth football coaches are facing criminal charges in connection with a bloody fist fight in front of dozens of players and paren...
-
NY Post has exclusive on Pirro giving money to State GOP Fred Dicker of the NY Post has an exclusive about Jeanine Pirro given money ...
-
Name: Ralph D. Amicucci, Esq. Firm Name: Amicucci & Associates, P.C. Office Address: 62 Highview Terrace, Pleasantville, NY 10570 ...
-
The Providence College outdoor men's and women's track team competed at the Brown Invitational today, Saturday, April 13. http://www...
-
JOURNAL NEWS: Judge rejects ex-Yonkers schools chief's discrimination claim; keeps slander, breach claims YONKERS: A federal judge has...
-
The firm currently has a $180.00 target price on the stock. Shares of ITV PLC traded up 0.55% during mid-day trading on Thursday, hitting $1...
-
Before your workout goes by in a blur, slow down and don't run as hard. It will serve you well. http://running.competitor.com/2013/04/tr...
-
New York State Sen. Shelley Mayer is doubling down on her call for MGM to drop a lawsuit against victims of last year’s Las Vegas massacre. ...
-
Eyeing more secure alternatives to Social Security numbers, lawmakers in the U.S. are looking abroad. The Senate Commerce Committee question...
Popular Harrod's News Of The World Posts - Last 30 Days
-
NY Post has exclusive on Pirro giving money to State GOP Fred Dicker of the NY Post has an exclusive about Jeanine Pirro given money ...
-
Two Nevada youth football coaches are facing criminal charges in connection with a bloody fist fight in front of dozens of players and paren...
-
World MORE ABOUT Donald Trump Robert Mueller Hillary Clinton Russia 'Everything I've Done Is 100 Percent...
-
VERIFIED: We Found Brian Harrod - Find Brian Harrod in New York, Don't Waste Countless Hours Looking for Brian Harrod. PUBLIC RECO...
-
REMEMBERING THE PAST: Many in White Plains miss the great mayors who served homeowners so well in the past. THINGS WENT DOWNHILL: Unl...
-
Name: Ralph D. Amicucci, Esq. Firm Name: Amicucci & Associates, P.C. Office Address: 62 Highview Terrace, Pleasantville, NY 10570 ...
-
Former Republican Sen. Jeff Flake is endorsing Vice President Kamala Harris because of his conservative values — not in spite of them — he s...
-
MORE ABOUT Miami Open V. Williams Sloane Stephens Continues Resurgence by Reaching Miami Open Final New York Times ...
-
In about 3 hours, the #YonkersPoliceDepartment impounded almost 30 mopeds, scooters, and motorcycles. These vehicles had everything from r...
Popular Harrod's News Of The World Posts - All Time
-
Two Nevada youth football coaches are facing criminal charges in connection with a bloody fist fight in front of dozens of players and paren...
-
NY Post has exclusive on Pirro giving money to State GOP Fred Dicker of the NY Post has an exclusive about Jeanine Pirro given money ...
-
PHOTO: Ernest Webb is facing a federal murder charge for allegedly shooting Dean Daniels to death in Mount Vernon on Sept. 22, 2014....
-
Heartless Rob Astorino's Department of Social Services (DSS) is known for cruelly ignoring the needs of poor children, seniors the dis...
-
March was certainly a month to remember for Luke Bryan. His March 5 release, Spring Break...Here to Party , debuted at the number one spot o...
-
NASSAU COUNTY, NY: News In And Around Brookville (Brian Harrod RoundupNewswires.com Editor-At-Large)Proposed beer garden faces opposition Newsday Dec 25, 2017 Cops: Man found shot 'numerous times' Ne...
-
TAX DEADBEAT: New York State Had To Place A Tax Lien On Senate Candidate Julie Powers Killian Multi-Million Dollar Estate Mega State ...
-
The Community Builders Inc. has obtained $38.3 million in financing to assist in the development of Cottage Place Gardens Phase III. The ...
-
WHITE PLAINS – A Yonkers man, Friday, pled guilty in Westchester County Court to stabbing another man to death in the Ridge Hill Movie Th...
No comments:
Post a Comment