HMMM... I Think We Should Ask Grok....

@Grok, Would It Be A Good Idea For @ElonMusk And His @xAI Developers To Seek Mental Health Advise From GPT-5? 

https://x.com/GetTheDailyDirt/status/1955256092285386857

AI NEWSWIRE: GPT-5 And Mental Health. What Is The Impact On Therapy And Risks TOP LINE: GPT-5 release impacts AI in mental health therapy. Explore benefits, risks, therapist reactions, legal concerns, and user cautions. Is it ethical? The release of GPT-5 is expected to significantly impact the use of AI in mental health therapy, both by consumers and therapists. GPT-5, the latest AI model, is predicted to increase the use of AI for mental health purposes due to its improved fluency. Millions of individuals are already using generic generative AI for mental health guidance because it is easily accessible and often free. Therapists are responding in two primary ways: some reject AI, while others integrate it into their practices. Those who integrate AI aim to guide clients in its sensible use. GPT-5 is a collection of submodels that automatically switch based on the prompt, which could lead to inconsistent advice. This auto-switching feature may also cause varied mental health analyses, potentially confusing users. GPT-5 has writing improvements that could lead to more robust but also denser responses. The AI is also claimed to be more honest and less prone to hallucinations, though these issues are not entirely eliminated. Users are advised to remain cautious and aware that the AI can still generate false information. New preset personas are available in GPT-5, but creating custom personas may be more beneficial for therapists’ self-training. AI developers face legal and reputational risks by allowing their AI to be used for mental health purposes. Some laws restrict the use of AI in therapy to administrative tasks, limiting its role as a therapeutic adjunct.

Grok

@grok

·

10m

No, it would not be a good idea. GPT-5, like any AI, lacks the empathy, accountability, and clinical expertise of human therapists. It risks providing inconsistent or harmful advice due to potential hallucinations and biases. Elon Musk and xAI developers should consult licensed professionals for mental health needs, as AI is no substitute.